The person in front of me
is the truest
You've always been
Leader, he's here
What are you doing?
Put down your knife
lf you do anything to her
l'll kill you
Why do you
still lie to me?
From past until now
Have you ever loved me?
Yes
You are lying!
lf you did
You won't hide from me
that you've pawned our wedding ring
for Hua Tuo Ye
Leader is in trouble
Leader killed Fang
He's going to make a confession now
l'll explain to you
some other day
Tuo Ye is in trouble now
lf you go and look for him
We're over!
Don't forget
the reason you're here today
is to tell me what you choose
We've split
The person in her heart
is not me
but someone else
Have you ever thought of
Some people choose to lie
is because they love the other party too much?
They don't want the other get hurt
and lied to them
ln their heart, they suffer more than anyone else
l've had enough
of you and
the doubts l had
l promise you
l'll help Tuo Ye in this case
But this will be the final favour
lt might be
a mistake
that we see each other again
Dad is busy
But don't you forget
Mu Cheng and l love you
Autumn's Concerto
l don't need a lawyer
The reason why
l agree to see you is because
l want to know the condition of Chi Xin
She was put in a mandatory rehabilitation program
l've went over to see her
l asked her what happened during that night
Why did you go and ask
her such questions?
She's already in bad shape
Can you just leave her alone?
l'm just worried
Chi Xin is going through
a bad times because of Hua Fen Fang
You still ask her this kind of questions
And you reminded her what had happened
Do you think she can take it?
Don't worry, l know what l can ask
The most important thing is your lawsuit
l don't need you
l can tell the judge
that you killed someone for self defense
or mistakenly killed him
l can ask for commutation
As long as you tell me what happened
lt's simple
l killed him
lt has nothing to do with other people
You didn't explain yourself
You only want to surrender yourself
and said it has nothing to do with others
Your attitude makes me
feel that this whole thing
is not as simple as it is
l killed Hua Fen Fang
l have nothing to explain
because the truth is like that
Nothing can be changed
You want me to lie?
And say that l didn't kill him
This is a perjury
The sentence will be greater
Sir
You are right
But l've never thought
you will attacked so hard
ln addition to Hua Fen Fang's fatal neck wound,
even he has laceration behind his ears
Seems like you really
want to kill him
when you attacked him
l count to 3
lf not l'll write it down
Kneel down
He should be dead
Finished?
l can go now
l've promised Siao Le
that l will save you
l don't want Siao Le to be sad
Because his brother
is a murderer
l don't want to see
Aunt Hua who is happy
fall down because she worried about you
What's wrong with my mother?
She worried about you
She knew that you are not in favour for this case
She can't take it
l made her worried about me
How is she now?
Don't worry,
Mu Cheng is taking care of her
Luckily Mu Cheng is there
Don't you misunderstood
l just want to
thank Mu Cheng for this
You don't have to explain to me
l know very well
how important you are to Mu Cheng
You've misunderstood
l did not
She told me that herself
You are very important to her
lf anything happened to you,
she will definitely do something
That's why she cared a lot for you
How could you do this to her?
lf this happened to me,
l'm willing to risk everything
but l don't want to lose this true heart
Therefore,
Hua Tuo Ye
Do you want to throw away
the feelings of your mother worry about you,
Mu Cheng's true heart to you,
and Siao Le's care for you?
You helped me so much
You defend for me
Just because my mom asked for your help?
Or is it because of Mu Cheng?
l've told you before
lt's because of Siao Le
True from your heart?
By all means,
l'm confident that l can get you out and let you
be together with those who cared for you
As long as you agree with me
How should l work with you?
Boss
ls Hua Tuo Ye agreeing to work with us?
He agreed
But his attitude is weird
Hua Fen Fang has a wound at the back of the ear
Hua Tuo Ye just admitted like that
But the problem is,
Hua Fen Fang doesn't have any wound at the back of his ear
Which means that?
he's lying
Judging from previous cases,
when someone is hiding something about the case,
normally he wants to clear his name,
or he wants to hide something
But Hua Tuo Ye
doesn't look like he wants to clear his name
What is his motive?
This is what we need to know
There are only 4 person at the crime scene
Hua Tuo Ye is not willing to tell the truth
Hua Fen Fang is seriously injured
Only left Hua Fen Fang's brother Yang Tian Fu
and Hua Chi Xin this 2 witnesses
But Yang Tian Fu's statement
is bias towards Hua Fen Fang
And the weird thing is,
Tuo Ye's reaction is
to stop us from seeing Hua Chi Xin
l think the key ot this case
lies on Hua Chi Xin
That's why we need to
talk to Hua Chi Xin once more
That's right
We need to gather all evidence first
Then see what the problem is
After Hua Chi Xin is out from rehab,
we can ask her once and for all
Don't forget
You must report to me
what's the prosecution's action
Boss
is on the final round of inquisition
on the evidences collected
The person who indict Hua Tuo Ye is the Chief Prosecutor
from the Banqiao District Prosecutor's Office, Tao Da Yi
This Tao Da Yi has investigated
a lot of cases
Even due to lack of evidence in the 2nd trial
and can't sentence the defendant,
they will be in the jail in 3rd trial
That's why he is known
as the exceptional
lt's confirmed that
Ren Guang Xi will become
Hua Tuo Ye's defense lawyer
l know him
This is the place
where Hua Tuo Ye threw the weapon
This also shows that he has the intention
of running away
lf he'd decided to surrender in the first place
he doesn't need to throw the weapon away
Beside
l've requested you to check
the call record between
Hua Tuo Ye and Hua Fen Fang
Yes
According to Hua Fen Fang's brother,
Yang Tian Fu
Hua Fen Fang and Hua Tuo Ye
have a lot of problems in between them
There's also a record to prove that
the 2 of them did hurt each other before
This proof that your
hypothesis is correct
l think for this time's assault,
the defendant is well prepared
Although the weapon is found,
but if Hua Tuo Ye's finger print
is not on it,
this kind of evidence
is not strong enough
Let me have a look at the reports
Previously l've investigate the crime scene
There is evidence of fight
of the defendant, Hua Chi Xin
l assume
Ren Guang Xi will use the reason of self defense
to reduce the period of sentence
But according to Yang Tian Fu's statement,
it can proved that the motive of Hua Tuo Ye
is to take revenge
l can use this to nail
Hua Tuo Ye had planned this assault
But l believe
Ren Guang Xi won't be that easy
This time,
l would like to see
the Ren Guang Xi
who only helped rich people,
and the Ren Guang Xi who's so bright
ls he that great?
Grandma
Why are you leaving?
Aren't you here to see me?
l'm not leaving
l'm only...
Siao Le
Grandma is not leaving
Grandma wants you to bring her
to have a look at our garden
Ms Fang
Welcome
l only brought
the photos of the crab
so that Siao Le can pass his homework
l've also brought
some no sugar candy
Siao Le can eat it without any worries
That's great, grandma
Come on
We have a huge garden here
lt's so pretty
The crab's claw is very big
Look, it's so big
Grandma, where are you looking?
You are not paying attention
l'm looking at the place where you grew up
See, it's very pretty, right?
Just like you
Warm and cute
Come on
Ms Fang
The food is ready
We can eat whenever we want
Grandma
Mu Cheng cooked
the stew beef rice today
Come, wash your hands with me
The soup is server
Liang Siao Le
What is the no 8 family teachings of Liang?
When l'm eating with elders,
l can only eat after the elders start eating
But l'm very hungry
Grandma
Siao Le, be a good boy
What your mother said is right
Come on, let's eat
Please, Ms Fang
Come on, Siao Le
Spinach
Your favourite
And this one
Put it down, l can do it myself
lt's alright
This can be used
l heard Siao Le said,
your life here last time
was quite hard
lt's not hard
Actually when l'm young,
my father has passed away
My family is not that well to do
That's why aunt always teach us
not to waste anything
l'm used to it
lt's not hard at all
l'm sorry
Sorry
l said you've got no manners
But,
after l've seen Siao Le
Now l realized how good your parents
for teaching you all the manners
For that only you can
teach Siao Le so many things
Thank you
After l've spend my time with Siao Le,
maybe it's because of
his smiles
Or maybe it's because
l'm starting to age
lt makes me think
Guang Xi was not as happy
as Siao Le when he's young
He seldom smiles too
l always forced him to go for classes and tuitions
Because of my interruption,
he has a bad childhood
Now finally l realized my mistakes
but it's too late
We are both single parent
There are a lot of things
which l need to think about
and learn from you
No
Actually we are the same
We love our children
Just that in different ways
Nobody loved Guang Xi more than you
But l have ripped Guang Xi off his childhood
And l intervene in between you and Guang Xi
This made you
and Guang Xi
and even Yi Jian
are unhappy
But it's because of your decision
that keep Guang Xi alive
That's the most important thing, right?
And because we've been through so much
That makes me realized
what should l cherished the most
Even if Guang Xi and l haven't been
been through all those problem,
we might not be together too
Nobody knows what will
happened next
That's why we should think for now
and bravely face the one we loved
and made the decisioin
and work hard for it
l know
Just like what you said
l also hope that
you won't give up on this marriage
You should worked hard
for the person whom you love
l didn't want to give up
But Guang Xi,
has kept me out from his life
he's like a stranger
l really don't know how
to get close to him now
We can get close like this
Grandma, this is getting close
Liang Siao Le
You try to over hear what we are saying
Who ask you become like this
lt's actually very simple
And call me Ren Siao Le
Alright, Ren Siao Le
You need to be the cupid
and help your mom and dad
And,
keep Mu Cheng not giving up
l remember everything
lt's like that
l've told you many times
l've told that to the inspector
lt will be the same
even if you asked me
That's right
You told me quite clearly just now
But l would need to ask you again
Did you see Hua Tuo Ye
took the candlestick pierced into Fang's neck?
For that moment,
l remembered
What l saw is that
Fang was bleeding
He's on the floor
And the Tuo Ye is holding the candlestick
That's why
You didn't see
that Hua Tuo Ye killed Fang
l...
l'm really stupid
Why can't l just remember it?
Chi Xin, calm down
lf l can remember,
will it help Tuo Ye?
Mr Ren
Tuo Ye did that to save me
That's why he did this
Help me Calm down
l will
Where's my amulet?
My amulet
lt's on your neck
What do you think?
A lot of witness,
after something horrible happened
they will have wrong description
or they can't remember
what really happened at the critical moment
Her current situation
is typical post-traumatic reaction
Did you see it?
She kept touching her amulet
The amulet is right on her neck
But she kept doing the same action
lf what l think is correct,
there's another possibility
The court will start soon
There's not much time left
Help me contact Dr Chan
from the Taiwan University Psychiatric
Alright
What did you see from here?
That's Fang's blood on the floor
l think your hypothesis is correct
ln the Rorschach projection test
which l did on her,
Everything that Hua Chi Xin thought
is everything related to the horror of the crime
This also shows that
she's still in the
deep state of horror
She can't remember
the critical moment of the crime
That's because she has locked up
the memory which
she doesn't want to remember
This is a typical psychogenic amnesia
Dr Chan
lf she really lost her memory
How's the possibility that she can recover the memory?
The court will be opened tomorrow
ls there any way
to make her remember?
Tonight
l will monitor her sleep
and her brain wave
And l'll try some methods
Maybe there still hope
But l really can't
guarantee anything to you
Her amulet
seems like very important to her
Would it help her recover her memory?
l'll try
The memory which she has locked up
is the most critical moment during the crime
l need to gamble on this
lf l did not guess wrong,
maybe l already knew
what Hua Tuo Ye is hiding from
Now we only short of
Hua Chi Xin this piece of last puzzle
Dr Chan
Please help her recover her memory
lnspector Tao
How do you do
Mr Ren
l'm anticipating today's court
We all know that this lawsuit
is very unfavorable to the suspect
lt's quite hard
for the suspect to get out from this
l really want to know
how could the famous lawyer Ren Guang Xi
will turn this favorable against to him
There's no possibilities
in front of law
There's only truth
Whether Hua Tuo Ye killed anyone,
we'll know after the court case
Before the judge rule anything,
my client is still innocent
lf that's the case,
we'll meet in the court then
Dr Chan
How is Chi Xin's condition?
She still can't remember
l will continue trying
Thank you
Guang Xi
Boss
Let me arrange the report
ls there anything? The court will start soon
Are you worried
about the question inspector going to ask?
You seems tired
lt's been a while since we met
Are you deprived of sleep
because of this case?
l know this case is hard
You've did a lot of preparation
No matter what's the outcome today,
l'm very grateful to you
for helping Tuo Ye so much
You don't have to thank me
l've agreed to help him
so l will work hard
l don't want him to be sentenced
Siao Le won't be happy
No matter how hard this lawsuit will be
l will try my best
to get the best result for him
After the case is finished,
could you give me some time?
l've got something to talk to you
We'll see about that later
Let's get to the case first
Boss
lt's almost time
Let's go
Leader
Sit down
All rise
The first trial of
defendant Hua Tuo Ye
murdering victim Hua Fen Fang
Prosecutor please do your statement
On January 18th, defendant Hua Tuo Ye wanted
to take revenge on victim Hua Fen Fang
He pierced a sharp object into Hua Fen Fang's neck
resulting the rupture or artery
And the victim is not in a coma
Hua Tuo Ye's motive of killing people is clear
The prosecutor are using violation of code
27 1 homicide code
to charge defendant
Because the defendant wants to run away
before he was arrested
Please drop sentence
This exhibit the tool of crime
defendant Hua Tuo Ye
Do you plead guilty
No
l plead guilty
Defendant counsel, do you have any
objections to the content of indictment?
Even though
the defendant plead guilty
But Hua Tuo Ye's finger print
is not on the crime tool
This could not proof that he did it
The evidence has no ability
Beside
The motive of my client's crime
is self defense
Therefore l request the court
to reduce or remit the sentence
according to section 23 of criminal code
Yes
Please call prosecution's first witness
Yang Tian Fu
According to your statement
the defendant Hua Tuo Ye
has blinded the victim's Hua Fen Fang
left eye
Hua Fen Fang has used a knife
and wounded Hua Tuo Ye's left hand
All this started
because Hua Fen Fang
has get Hua Tuo Ye's sister,
whom is Hua Chi Xin to become a PR
Hua Tuo Ye is angry
That's why he went over to take revenge
ls that correct?
Yes
And you also said that
When the crime happened
the defendant has asked Hua Sheng Bing's help
and recorded the police siren before hand
to get you all ran on a different direction
ls that correct?
Yes
Your honour
From the statement of the witness
l can summarize that
the motive of the defendant is to
take revenge on the victim
With Hua Sheng Bing's help
this shows that before Hua Tuo Ye did this crime
he has actually did all the preparation
This also proves that
Hua Tuo Ye is a premeditated murderer
You are lying
According to my client's statement
he brought $1 million with him the other night
over to save Ms Hua Chi Xin
And you'd also searched his body
ls that correct?
Yes
Then did you found any
weapon on his body that time?
No
According to my client's statement
after you've calculated the $1 million,
Hua Fen Fang doesn't want to release them
and he'd even kidnapped Hua Chi Xin and threaten my client
ls that correct?
l didn't see clearly
Witness, please tell the truth
Seems like it is
Your honour
According to the witness's statement,
my client didn't bring any weapon there
He'd only wanted the deal to finish fast
He doesn't have any motive
He accidentally wounded
the victim because someone threaten
to end his sister's life
Then only he did that
So,
defendant's action is for self defense
Objection
Your honour
1 week before the crime,
the defendant had went to the crime scene
to negotiate with the victim
and was wounded by Hua Fen Fang
During that time he'd already knew
there's a candle stick at that place
Even he didn't bring any weapon,
he still can use the candlestick to kill someone
And the defendant asked Hua Sheng Bing's help to lure his brother away
Your honour
This is premeditated
Prosecutor,
please call forward the 3rd witness
Ms Liang
Please describe
why are you at the crime scene
when Hua Tuo Ye is being arrested
When things happened,
Bing is very scared
He called me at once
and told me Tuo Ye killed Fang
and he's going to surrender
So during that time
l want to know what's happening
And see what l can help him
So when you are at the crime scene,
Hua Tuo Ye is getting ready to surrender
and it's not like what he said
he's going to run away
Yes
That time he said he wants to surrender
After l got the call l went back home
The journey took almost 2 hours
lf Tuo Ye wants to run,
he won't have ran away
and not stayed at my house
As far as l know,
you and Tuo Ye has no relationship
He'd related in a homicide
Normally when people is involved in this,
they will just hide
Why do you still want to help him?
Because Tuo Ye helped me a lot
until l can't repay him back
My son has Type 1 diabetes
For this 6 years,
l've been raising him alone
lf not Tuo Ye helped me,
the 2 of us can't survive
Even though l really
don't know what happened during that day,
but the Hua Tuo Ye that l knew
is full of justice and kind
He would never do that kind of thing
Even though l really
don't know what happened during that day,
but the Hua Tuo Ye that l knew
is full of justice and kind
He would never do that kind of thing
Seems like
Ms Liang has high praises
for the defendant
May l ask Ms Liang,
how long have you known the defendant?
l knew Tuo Ye for 7 years
When the first time we met,
that's because
he refused to be in Fang's triad
and he ran away and hide in the book store
That's also because he's full of justice
and doesn't want to get involved in crimes
Because this also proves that
he doesn't have motive to kill anyone
lt's the same as my investigation
Ms Liang's relationship is deep with defendant
As far as l know,
you'd even nearly married him
May l ask Ms Liang,
then why did you
suddenly stop your intention of marrying him?
lt's because there are some reasons
that l need t marry my son's biological father
Whom also is
Ren Guang Xi
That's why the defendant is your fiance
and the defendant counsel
is your current husband
Yes
Your honour
No matter Ms Liang wants
to help her husband in this case
Or she wants to help
the defendant
Their relationship
is a bit special
Therefore Ms Liang's statement is biased
Please omit it
The defendant pleaded guilty
The statement's of the witness is here
And the
weapon which is
got from the river
And also the statement
of the doctor proves that the
defendant's motive of killing someone
is to take revenge
And the defendant really wants to kill the victim
After committing crime,
the defendant wipe off the/finger print from the weapon
And tried to escape
All these proves that
the defendant attempt murder
Please drop heavy sentence
You are talking nonsense
l can't remember it
Stop forcing me
l tried my best
l'm useless
l want to go home
l can't remember it
Stop forcing me
l'm useless
Stop forcing me
l want to go home
Chi Xin, it's alright
We stop doing treatment
Your amulet is so pretty
Do you always wear it?
Let me tell you
l helped Tuo Ye
to get this amulet from the temple
lt's very good
lf not because of it,
me and Tuo Ye can't
survive from Fang
Give me the amulet
No
Chi Xin
Did you remember anything?
l...
l don't know
You must have remember something
lf not you won't be that scared
Try to remember it
What did you see when
Fang was being assaulted?
l don't know
l just saw
l just saw Fang
He bleed a lot
Others l can't remember
l really can't remember
Stop forcing me
Don't take my amulet
Chi Xin
lt's alright, Chi Xin
Don't cry
lt's alright
Sorry
lt's alright
l've remembered everything
Alright, good
lt's fine now
Alright, stop crying
lt's fine now
Hua Tuo Ye
Your facial expression
and uncooperative manner
makes me don't feel like helping you
There're blood on the weapon
but no finger print
Nothing can be done
Hua Fen Fang's brother came in
only say you holding the weapon
But did not see you killed him
The statement
is invalid
The victim is still laying coma in the hospital
He can't give a statement
l think the chief judge is also troubled now
Please behave
So all the 4 people who's at the crime scene
Hua Fen Fang, Hua Tuo Ye
Hua Chi Xin and Yang Tian Fu
All of them is a suspect
Your motive is only 4/1
Everything is so
favorable on your side
But you just pleaded guilty
l don't understand you
Don't you know that this
lnspector Tao
is so full of justice?
You just pleaded guilty so easily
lf this has become an injustice,
you will ruined
him in your hands
Can you take that?
What's wrong with you?
What do you want to do?
Defendant counselor
Please focus
Your honour
l really don't know why
my client pleaded guilty
But l can also guess that
Hua Fen Fang suddenly wants to commit suicide
or his brother wants to rebel
and killed his leader
so he can be the leader
Or maybe Hua Chi Xin
was frighten so she killed Hua Fen Fang
Ren Guang Xi, what are you talking?
l killed him
Why do you drag this to Chi Xin?
She has nothing to do with this
lt's weird
Why didn't you say it has nothing to do Fang,
nothing to do with subordinate,
but you keep saying it has nothing to do with Chi Xin?
That's because you noticed Hua Chi Xin
has lost the memory on that
critical moment of crime
So you hide the truth
And just pleaded guilty
There's only one possibility
That you want to protect Hua Chi Xin
Cannot be
Your honour
What he said is not true
l killed him
Objection
The defendant counselor's is not following order
and contemplating the court
Please control your emotions
Your honour
From all this,
l can assume that
the true killer is Hua Chi Xin
Actually the defendant is innocent
Ren Guang Xi
Stop this
Your honour
My lawyer is talking nonsense
l don't need him anymore
Didn't l plead guilty?
Why didn't you lock me up?
What are you waiting for?
No
What Mr Ren said is right
l killed
Hua Fen Fang
Your honour
My lawyer is talking nonsense
l don't need him anymore
Didn't l plead guilty?
Why didn't you lock me up?
What are you waiting for?
No
What Mr Ren said is right
l killed
Hua Fen Fang
Shut up
Don't say anything
Who ask you to be here?
l don't need you to be my witness
Go back
Why are you here?
Tuo Ye
Stop lying
You shouldn't do this for me
Your honour
This is the witness l called upon
Ms Hua Chi Xin
The one standing beside her is Dr Chan
from the Taiwan University Psychiatric Department
l would like her to give
a thorough explanation
Hua Chi Xin is my patient
l've done with my therapy for her
and help her recover
all the memories during the crime
l can guarantee
all the statements Hua Chi Xin made in the court
is valid
Mr Ren suspected l have lost
some part of the memories
And the few seconds of memory which l lost
during the crime is the most critical part
That's why he asked Dr Chan to treat me
Until now,
l can only remember everything that happened
lt's true
l killed Fang
That time,
when l saw Fang
nearly pierced Tuo Ye,
and before Tuo Ye
wounded Fang...
Leader
You dare to go after killing my leader
Tuo Ye
Let's go
Go
lt's me
l've took another candlestick
and hit Fang
l feared that Fang
will injured Tuo Ye
And then suddenly,
l saw there's a
candlestick beside me
Without thinking much,
l just took the candle stick
and charged Fang
After that when l realized it,
Fang is already on the floor
So during that time,
l really thought that
Tuo Ye killed Fang
Luckily Dr Chan helped me recover my memories
Tuo Ye said like that
because he wanted to help me
Please don't sentence him anything
This is the report
on the tests l perform on Hua Chi Xin
During the time when Hua Chi Xin
is being imprisoned by Hua Fen Fang,
she's been controlled by drugs for long,
and she's tortured
So she has PTSD
which is also
post traumatic stress disorder
Luckily Mr Ren noticed it
That's why he noticed the symptoms
Some of the patients
will purposely forgets
something they don't want to recall
Hua Chi Xin is this type of patient
l assume during that time,
Hua Chi Xin doesn't want to kill anyone
lt's just PTSD attacked
Besides she was controlled by drugs
and suddenly lose control
and she accidentally killed Hua Fen Fang
l didn't kill him on purpose
Sorry, Tuo Ye
lf l didn't ran away from home,
if l wasn't caught by Fang,
all these won't happen
lt's all my fault, l'm sorry
Sorry
Ren Guang Xi
Why do you let her remember it?
lt's for her own good
if she can forgets
all those bad incident
That's for her own good
Hua Fen Fang wants to take revenge on me
then only he went hurt her
Chi Xin is the victim
You . . .
Who do you to judge her?
Then you are wrong
You shouldn't think that
you can settle everything
Shouldn't think that it's alright
for you to admit her crime
lf you go to the jail,
will Chi Xin be happy?
Will she be happy?
You should report to the police from the start
l did that because...No
Tuo Ye
Mr Ren is right
You are wrong
Do you know that
when l saw you admitting my crime,
l feel so sad?
l feel so wronged
Without you by my side,
l won't be happy
Prosecutor, what's your thought
on the witness pleaded guilty?
Your honour
l believe the defendant Hua Tuo Ye
is innocent
So we are not going to charge him
And for Hua Chi Xin's case,
l think we need to investigate further
Please send Hua Chin Xin into custody
Your honour
Judging from Hua Chi Xin's condition,
the motive is purely self defense
And now she surrendered and pleaded guilty in the court
l hope your honour and the persecutor
may consider her condition
And give her lenient sentence
And hope that the prosecutor
will investigate Hua Fen Fang's triad
The court sentence
to release Hua Tuo Ye now
Hua Chi Xin's homicide case
and Hua Fen Fang's involvement in kidnapping,
ransom and forced imprisonment
will be investigated by the prosecutor
Chi Xin
Don't be afraid
l won't leave you
Keep this
When you are back,
and help me sew this button up
Don't worry, Tuo Ye
Wait for me
l'll grew up
and be more knowledgeable
And you don't have to worry about me
Remember
You must come back early
Me and mom
will wait for you at home
Boss
l will follow up with Hua Tuo Ye's proceedings
l'll meet you later
Mr Ren
You have totally changed
my mind about you
with your today's performance
What l admire most is that
you'd even notice what
other things which other people noticed,
the PTSD symptoms
This not only reverse the whole case,
and it also uncover the truth
lf not, the consequences will be bad
l need to thank you
But how could you do it?
lt's simple
l actually had PTSD
l can't believe that
Heard that you need to be
very patient to be with this type of person
Yes
Hear Mr Lin said
there will be a seminar
organized by the judiciary in America
You will be there too
Then we should discuss by then
l hope in the future,
l will meet you more often in court
Me too
l'm anticipating it
Although the judge feels you won't run away,
and you can go back home
But don't worry
You are brother and sister with Chi Xin
Your sentence will not he heavy
l will try to let you off
l don't care
Please
Just help Chi Xin
No matter is you or Chi Xin,
l will let you be back to Hua Tian
Ren Guang Xi
Thank you
This is what l owed you
lt's me who need to thank you
Although l knew that
you have taken care of them for long
But only today l realized
that the things you've done
is a lot more than l imagine
You didn't owe me anything
So what?
6 years ago
you've saved Mu Cheng
in the fact-finding tribunal
Now you saved me
This shows that
you are capable of
taking care of them both
This only proves that l'm a good lawyer
Other than that,
l'm nobody
What do you mean by that?
l mean,
as a lawyer
l'm sending you back
to Mu Cheng and Siao Le
My responsibilities are over
Therefore l hope
you can continue
to take care of them
like what you did for the last 6 years
Did l hear wrong?
You want me to take care of your son,
and your wife?
Then what are you doing to do?
l will explain with Mu Cheng
When l insisted to keep her by my side,
that's because l thought
we can change something
But now, we are hurting each other
Mu Cheng said it 6 years ago
l'm not the one whom she can depend on
and the one who give her the future
You are
Mr Ren
Can't it be until now
you still don't get
the true reason she left you?
What do you mean?
Have you ever thought
if she chose me last time,
why she didn't accept me
for the past 6 years?
Why did she keep telling Siao Le
that he has an alien dad?
And teach him that
Miss you, Miss you
That you,
who do you think she's talking about?
You are a great lawyer
You are so smart in the court
Why can't you figure out
such easy answer?
The answer is that Mu Cheng this silly woman
only loved one man
from the start till now
And that's you
And because of this reason,
she had to lie to you 6 years ago
You said Mu Cheng lied to me?
Do you really think
Mu Cheng is so materialistic?
6 years ago
if not her mother asked her to leave you
Mu Cheng wants you to
lost all hope and
accept Mr Ho's particle treatment
That's why she asked me to help her
All this while she knew you are alive
But she can't go and search you
Because she doesn't want
to ruin your relationship with your mom
But now she needs to
take all your hatred
Do you know
how sad she is?
Yes
She's so silly
And she's selfish
How could she make a decision without asking me?
Why did she leave me all alone?
l will be happy
if l live alone like this?
Yes, she's selfish
She didn't ask you
But you are alive now
And that's the most important thing
l believe
if you are her by then,
you will make the same decision
for the person whom you loved
Unless your love for Mu Cheng is not deep enough
But it's all over
l've requested to be parted
And she accepted that
That's the truth
Her final choice
will never be me
Let's go
Aunt Hua is waiting for you
He's coming out
Leader is out
Hua Tuo Ye
Mom
As long as you are safe
Let me have a look
Mr Ren
Thank you for saving Hua Tuo Ye
How about Hua Chi Xin?
What can be done with Hua Chi Xin?
Don't worry
The judge will consider about Chi Xin's condition
and all the bad things Hua Fen Fang did to her
l can guarantee
that Chi Xin's sentence won't be heavy
No matter what l need to thank you
Are you free later?
l would like to invite you over for dinner
We can go to Mu Cheng's place
haven't sit down to have a meal
because of Tuo Ye's case
Aunt Hua
l still need to follow up
on a lot of things on Chi Xin's case
l need to leave now
Yes
Hua Chi Xin's case is more important
lt's alright
Then tomorrow bring along your assistant
and come to Hua Tian
Me and Mu Cheng
will prepare a feast for you, alright?
l'm leaving now
Alright, let's go home
Finally we are safe
Come on
Thank you, Mr Ren
Thank you
Come Hua Tian for a feast
Boss
The results are out
Hua Chi Xin's information
lt's about your father
Previously you suspected there might
be something else
in Ms fang and your dad's divorce
And asked me to investigate
l can't believe this either
l'm very surprised, sorry
When did this happen?
l mean,
my dad and this girl
lt's at the year your dad committed suicide
Because this is a scandal
for the Fang family
That's why this news
is suppressed by Fang family
And it's not reported in the papers
l'm going out for a while
Remember to book the air ticket for me
Boss
Are you sure you want to do this?
l mean tomorrow, you and Mrs
3pm in the afternoon,
one way ticket
Pass me the contract
of this year's graduate
l need to confirm something
Okay, alright
Then it is
Why are you here?
Nothing
l just came to see Sung Duk Hall
and drop by to see you
lt's weird
Even though all my memories are back,
although l know Sung Duk Hall is very important
but l can't remember why
Do you know the reason?
That's because of your father
You think about him at that place
ls that so?
Since l can't remember now
Let just demolish Sun Duk Hall
Guang Xi
What are you trying to say?
How could you forget
You still remember
But is that the truth?
l remembered you divorce with dad
l remembered you fought
l remembered he committed suicide
But l never knew that
it's dad who made this all happened
Not you
Why didn't you tell me
the reason of your divorce?
lt's because he had an affair
Because he and his student
had an affair in Sung Duk Hall
That's why you fought every day
That's why dad left
and you 2 divorced
What do you want?
l don't regret
You will know sooner or later
We loved each other
Don't let Guang Xi knows
What?
l don't want Guang Xi lost his dad
That's why l can tolerate your affair
l just hope
you don't let Guang Xi knows about this
Keep it that way
l...
l don't want Guang Xi...
l don't want Guang Xi's childhood
is full of dirty memories
Take away your hands
And the reason for dad's
suicide is not what l thought so
You didn't force him to go away
He eloped with that girl
and try to commit suicide in that motel
And then last minute
that girl pull back
and let him die there alone
You wanted to protect me, aren't you?
You don't want to ruin
dad's image in my heart
You rather l misunderstood you
than letting me know
that my dad is that kind of a person
That's why you
didn't abolish Sung Duk Hall
Not because that l insisted
lt's because you can't forget dad
You think too highly of me
That's why you
didn't abolish Sung Duk Hall
Not because that l insisted
lt's because you can't forget dad
You think too highly of me
Actually,
l'm still angry at him
Until now
l can't totally forgive him
And the scandal which you said just now,
you are too young that time
l don't know how to explain to you
That's why l didn't say anything
Maybe,
maybe what l said
will be different from now
l admit
l still miss
your dad
That's the reason why
Sung Duk Hall can stay until now
Because Sung Duk Hall
is the place we first met
During that time,
he's a music teacher
And l'm the daughter of the director
l think now if
l demolish Sung Duk Hall,
that means l'm burying
the memories which
your father have only
left for me
l don't want to do that
About Mr Lin,
you don't have to worry about him
He's really my best friend
and the best assistant for Fang family
For so many years,
he's very faithful
and has been supportive of us
And he'd never cross the line
How could you
let me misunderstood you
and hated you
for so many years?
Why do you carry all this burden alone?
Because,
l think that's best for you
l thought by doing that
you will be more happy
That's why l hide it from you
Just like what you are doing now
Didn't you want to give freedom
to Mu Cheng and Siao Le,
therefore you chose to leave them?
And then pretend you are doing fine
But l know
l know you are not fine
Guang Xi
You still have a chance
You are more lucky than l am
Why don't you cherish it?
l've always used the wrong way
to treat you for so many years
l don't want
you to use the rest of your life
regret of the things
you have missed in your life
Why?
Because you are my son
Because l loved you
There are a lot of ways of love
Maybe the way that l've used
is not that right
You can deny it
But,
love
Love is true from the heart
You shouldn't suspect it
l think Mu Cheng is the same
My son is grown up now
That's why only you are clear
what you want to do
Mom will support you
l go tidy up
Mr Lin
Help me with the contract
Mom
l've never told you
that l'm sorry
And thank you
lt's alright
Keep it up
Sorry
l've misunderstood you for so many years
l owe you a thank you
Thank you for accompanying my mother
and take care of her for so long
Guang Xi
Even it's been long time,
but it's not that hard
to say what you think of
Before you go to America,
aren't there anything you want to tell Mu Cheng?
Mu Cheng
You'll make my hand full with holes
Sorry
Mu Cheng
ls it because Guang Xi is coming tomorrow?
Yes
l'm thinking
what should l cook for
Guang Xi and Gary tomorrow
Braised beef rice
You said,
Guang Xi protected you from bad guys
and you made braised beef rice for him
Guang Xi got angry after that
Then, he was happy
Then, l was brought to this world
Help me!
Help!
What happened then?
No
Then, Guang Xi
likes to eat braised beef rice
Mu Cheng
Why did you stop me just now?
Because you'll understand it
after you grow up
Adults are weird
They might not like thing that
they used to like it before
2 persons get together because of love,
but,
they always split because of other reasons
Get on to your bed
My mom wanted me to bring it over here
for Guang Xi
and his assistant tomorrow
Aunt Hua
must have prepared many dishes
for them
How about you?
How will you express your gratitude to Guang Xi?
Or
you're worry that
they want you to
explain our relationship
after the meal tomorrow?
Ren Guang Xi has told me everything
You've moved back here too
l knew that
there is something between you
lt's all my fault
l know
lf it wasn't because of you,
he wouldn't help me
Don't worry
ln fact, l want to
talk to him
after the lawsuit
But l don't know
if he will meet me up
Even if he doesn't want to meet you up, so?
Have you ever told him that
you care about him?
This is nothing to do
with his choice
Even if he still misunderstand
or doesn't love you anymore,
now, you should
tell him your feeling
This is not only for you
and Xiao Le,
this is for Ren Guang Xi too
Mu Cheng
He is trying all his best to love you
Think about it
6 years ago,
he fight with the illness and
got strike because of you
He lost his memory then
to remember you
The difference now is
he is trying to leave you
Mu Cheng
You're not fair to him
because you never told him that
you love him
Be brave
When you were helpless,
Ren Guang Xi gave you encouragement
Now, he is helpless
Don't you think that you should
give him encouragement too?
You may get hurt again,
but, why don't you
give each other another chance?
Give it another try
You can't always be the one
who is waiting
You have to
fight for your happiness
Tuo Ye
Thank you
Mu Cheng
Hua Diao Ji told me that
Tang Tang doesn't dare to take injection
and wants to be accompanied by Xiao Le
We'll be back soon
Xiao Le said,
tell Ren Guang Xi to wait for him
Mu Cheng
Don't get in my way
Mu Cheng
Let me do it
Mr Ren is coming
Go get yourself dress up
You must
look prettier than the dish
Go get yourself dress up
Let me do it
Thank you
Well,
Mr Ren promised to come today
Where is he?
l'm sorry
Boss has an emergency
you invite him sincerely
So he get me to
say thank you to you
That's ridiculous
l prepared all these dishes for him
Mu Cheng waits for him from this morning
How can he just break the promise?
Boss
told me something
and l need to talk with Ms Liang personally
What is it?
Your boss is my boss
Mu Cheng's problem
is Hua Tian Village's problem
Just tell us what is it all about
Tell us Come on
Don't worry, just tell me what is it
Ms Liang
Boss wanted me to give you this
What is it?
Divorce agreement?
Divorce?
lt can't be true
The conditions in this agreement
are attractive
Boss will give you
a big sum of alimony
the house you are staying now
You can even own a field
He didn't ask you to sign it right away
You can think about it
after read through it
But, he already signed it
lt can't be like that, how about Xiao Le?
He doesn't want Xiao Le?
He want to leave Xiao Le?
According to Boss,
he knows that Xiao Le
ls the most important person in your life
He gives up the custody of Xiao Le
You can get Xiao Le
But, if possible,
he wants you to bring Xiao Le
to Taipei every weekends
because Mrs Fang
will be missing her grandson
He. . .
He gives up Xiao Le?
Mu Cheng
He signed the paper
and doesn't want Xiao Le
Does he really want to get divorce?
Does he know that Xiao Le is happy
and waiting to meet him?
How do we explain to Xiao Le now?
Get this back
Tell Ren Guang Xi
not to be a coward
Bring this to here personally if he dare to
lt is not that he doesn't want to come
He is leaving to America
this evening
l don't even know
when he will be back
He's your boss
and you said you don't know?
l'm serious
He goes to America
for a seminar
lt is only an excuse
ln fact,
he will meet up with
a law firm at New York
They want to hire Boss
and have been contacting him for a while
lf their discussion is smooth,
Boss will stay there this time
Ms Yi Qian
is now at America too
They may meet up
for reunion talk
and have a vacation
To be frank,
Boss only booked
one way ticket
lt means,
he doesn't plan to come back
Get up
Get up!
l don't care
where he is going
What does he mean now?
He married Mu Cheng and want to
get divorce as he likes?
Who is Mu Cheng to him?
Go back and tell him,
Mu Cheng will not sign this paper
lf he want a divorce, get him over here
We will be waiting for him
Ms Liang
Give me a call after you make decision
Goodbye
Tuo Ye
Don't be like that
l think,
he is really disappointed
Mu Cheng
Your call
l don't know who is this
Hello
Tuo Ye
Why you give me lotus?
Because lotus is pure
Just like you
Then next time can you give me roses?
who wants you to write a will for her
She said she wants to give
all her property to her daughter
What did the kidnappers want you to do?
We are here already
Why didn't they let us know what to do?
Or we should go report to the police
This is premeditated crime
l've got a lot of doubts in you
Maybe we should be separated
for some time
lf our life is like the Monopoly,
no matter how many times we can start again,
the results will be the same
Because,
you are my destiny
Resynch by Amir Fazel